Hoping to be wrong

I headed out to Belmont early on Saturday morning, to visit the children at Anna House before watching workouts and visiting the backstretch.  As always, Belmont felt like a little city:  at Anna House, a half dozen or more teachers worked with children of varying ages as they played, learned, read, built, created; at the track, tram drivers carted around groups of visitors and tourists; on the backstretch, grooms and hotwalkers bathed, walked, and fed their equine charges.  As always, I was in awe of the range of tasks and talents that keep a racetrack running smoothly.

And I couldn’t help imagining what it might all look like if racing shuts down, even temporarily, in less than a month.  I kept envisioning things disappearing, like they do in cartoons, in a bubble that makes that sort of popping sound as things go away.

Pop!  There goes Anna House, and with it the child care on which backstretch workers depend. They won’t work on the backstretch any more, but they’ll need to work somewhere, even if only for a short time, and those workplaces won’t offer the same level of child care that Anna House does.

Pop!  There go concession stands.  I thought of the young woman with whom I spoke Saturday morning, who works in the grandstand on the weekends and attends college to earn her degree in education during the week.  What effect might unemployment, even if only for a few weeks, have on those plans?

Pop!  There go hundreds and hundreds of horses on the backstretch at Belmont and Aqueduct—without racing, where do they go?

Pop!  There go carpentry jobs, maintenance jobs, horse transport jobs, horse feed jobs, training jobs, not just on the Belmont backstretch, but across New York State.

I get that a lot of factors have combined to get New York racing to this point; I get that racing in the state might need to be re-envisioned; I get that racing, here and everywhere, needs to try to be self-sufficient instead of relying on money outside the sport.

But I don’t get, and I don’t accept, that once again, people at the bottom of the rung of the employment ladder are at the mercy of the folks in Albany who don’t face losing their jobs, or, more gallingly, at the mercy of the folks  at NYC-OTB who would like to profit off the work of others without paying them for it.

The inaction, lack of interest, and dearth of courage and compassion on the part of our elected officials are now, as they were several years ago during the franchise negotiations, inexcusable.  People in the state will be put out of work because they can’t keep their promises, because they can’t make a decision that should have been made nearly a decade ago, because they can’t provide the money, decisions, or leadership that New York racing deserves?

More than two years ago, when New York racing faced a similar shutdown as resolution of the franchise agreement dragged on, with similarly deplorable inaction by the elected representatives of New York’s citizens, I believed that common sense, compassion, and obligation would stop those representatives from bringing racing to a halt.  This time, I am not nearly so sanguine.

More than two years ago, I wrote, “I don’t believe that anyone involved could look at himself in the mirror after putting thousands of people out of a job, and out of a home.”  I was pretty confident then, and I was right.

But this time, I have no such faith in the power of conscience and of what’s right to rule the day.  I hope I’m wrong.

6 thoughts on “Hoping to be wrong

  1. This was a very well written article and you couldn’t have made your points any better. The NY racing industry isn’t the only affected party by the inability for politicians in this state to function in an even remotely productive level. Everyone that lives in this state suffers from the greed and stupidity in Albany.

    And I thought NJ was bad, shame on me.

    Call it youthful ignorance, but I’m confident that everything will be ok. This group of politicians has had too many hands in their pockets and are handcuffed but when backed against the wall something will be done. The “damage” everyone seems to be talking about that is done is a little overblown. Racing has had its issues for a long time, and by that more than 10 years. We’ll be ok.

  2. Well I sure hope the situation gets better across the Hudson. When Albany comes in with a check for $17 million (or thereabouts) and proclaims “carry on, everbody” that is going not going to cure the many woes of racing in the state of New York.

    If there is a shutdown, the NYRA employees, backstretch workers, and the horse racing customers should take heart that they have hit rock bottom and the road to recovery is right around the corner. I’m hoping any stoppage of racing is brief and of minimal inconvenience.

    This is a national game and Albany should be prepared for criticism from all four corners of the U.S. should they fail to correct the plight of thoroughbred racing in New York state within the next 6 months.

  3. As a backstretch worker, I don’t think I would feel NYRA or racing has hit “rock bottom” if we were to have any kind of stoppage. I would tilt towards the political climate in this state has hit rock bottom because the sport isn’t dead on any level in the state, country or globe.

    The results of Monmouth opening weekend in comparison to last weekend at Belmont from a handle perspective was interesting. Monmouth offered more races and much higher purses with better race conditions and still did not surpass NYRA’s total handle numbers. Maybe I read the handle numbers wrong so Teresa can correct me if I’m wrong.

  4. I wrote my State Senator Eric Adams a note today asking him to step up and get this NYRA deal done so there would be no interruption in racing in NY. He actually chairs the Committee on Racing, Gaming & Wagering so is a key member in Albany if a deal is going to happen this week. I am a big believer in hoping for the best, but we need more than hope this time around. We need someone with some political courage to stand up and take charge.

  5. I was woken at 3am with an email to say that common sense had prevailed. Now i’m an ex-politician I can definitely say it’s always shocked me that politicians in the US hold sway in the way that they do where racing is concerned

  6. Phew. Now if the state finally selects a VLT vendor…
    Here’s wishing the backstretch workers a good night’s sleep, and may we all dream of another summer in Saratoga – it may not top last year’s Travers and Woodward, but I’ll be content just to have the old place open.

Leave a comment