Easy Goer in the Gotham

This blasted flu that has kept me home from work all week is also, in all likelihood, going to keep me away from the Big A and the Gotham today. I’m hoping for some sort of miracle rally, but reports of the first big New York race of 2009 are probably, maddeningly, going to come second-hand. So in an attempt to rise above the flu-induced melancholy, here’s a quick look back at the 1989 Gotham, with first-hand accounts from those who were there.

The race took place over Aqueduct’s main track on April 8th, much later than it currently does, reflecting a more rigorous race schedule than this year’s Derby contenders will experience. The Wood was run two weeks later, on the 22nd, and the Derby two weeks after that. Easy Goer ran in all three, followed by the Preakness and the Belmont: five tough races in two months.

Demmi Stathopolos for Sports Illustrated described Easy Goer before the race:

The hot favorite for the Kentucky Derby looked every inch the star as he was led into the paddock at Aqueduct racetrack last weekend just before the 37th running of the Gotham Stakes. Easy Goer kicked his heels in the air a couple of times, rolled his eyes and danced down the ramp leading to the saddling enclosure. It was show time, and the son of Alydar was on the muscle, ready to dazzle the tough New York audience.

A few minutes later, this equine showman had set a new stakes record (1:32 2/5), breaking the mark set by Secretariat, and coming within a fifth of a second of the world record.

On the same day, across the country, another three-year-old began his collision course with New York’s favorite Derby prospect; Sunday Silence beat D. Wayne Lukas’s favored Houston (“The only colt who had appeared to be in [Easy Goer’s] league this season,” according to Steve Crist in the New York Times. Sunday who?), who came back to be unsaddled amid a chorus of boos.

Such an unappreciative audience, however, is nothing new to Sunday Silence, a colt once so ugly that nobody wanted him. As a yearling, this son of Halo had some notable defects in conformation: He was knock-kneed and “weedy”—horse lingo for scrawny. Twice he was taken to public auction, but there was so little interest in him that his principal owner, Arthur Hancock, bought back the horse both times. On the way home from the second auction, the driver of the colt’s van had a fatal heart attack while on the road. The van overturned, and a shaken Sunday Silence had to spend two weeks recovering at a clinic in Oklahoma. But when he finally got to the races last October, the ugly horse started to look darn good. (Stathopolos)

Even with Sunday Silence’s victory in California, Easy Goer was the unchallenged star of the day; in discussing the California race, Crist mentions only Houston’s loss—he never mentions Sunday Silence’s name.

In the Blood-Horse, Bill Finley wrote

In an effort so brilliant and stunning it will never be forgotten by anyone fortunate enough to witness it, Easy Goer went beyond mere brilliance, winning Aqueduct’s Gotham Stakes (gr. II) in 1:32 2/5, only one-fifth of a second slower than Dr. Fager’s world record for a mile and a full second faster than Triple Crown winner Secretariat’s stakes record…Easy Goer did it so effortlessly that he appeared capable of running far faster, a startling thought considering he is a 3-year-old and well away from his prime.

You can watch Easy Goer’s Gotham here:

YouTube video

Within a month, Sunday Silence would rise from relative obscurity to break the hearts of New York racing fans, but Easy Goer, whose distance limitations had been a question since his loss in the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile, came back to deny the California invader the Triple Crown in the 1989 Belmont.

Twenty years later, Shug McGaughey ships a colt from Florida to take the New York road to Kentucky. The support for Imperial Council hasn’t quite reached the near-fanatic status of that for Easy Goer, but a win today might change all that.

Crist, Steven. “Horse Racing; Easy Goer Romps.” New York Times. 9 April 1989. 6 March 2009.

“Easy Goer — 1989 Gotham Stakes.” 8 April 1989. Online video clip. YouTube. Accessed on 6 March 2009.

Finley, Bill. “On This Day.” The Blood-Horse. 8 April 2004. Originally published 8 April 1989. 6 March 2009.

Stathopolos, Demmi. “Auditions for the Derby.” Sports Illustrated Vault. 17 April 1989. 6 March 2009.

8 thoughts on “Easy Goer in the Gotham

  1. Thanks so much for remembering this champion in what was a sensational performance. I’m so sorry you are still down w/the flu. Maybe you can sneak out for the last 3 races and I am hoping Mr Fantasy takes this yaer’s edition of this great race. I’ll be there, and with the weather so nice here in NYC today, am hoping we get a nice crowd.

  2. Thanks for bringing mind to one of my favorite horses – Easy Goer – who ran heartbreakingly second in my favorite race of all-time, 1989 Preakness Stakes. Horse racing could really use a rivalry like the one 20 years ago between East vs. West, Shug vs. the Bald Eagle, and P. Val vs. Pat Day. I recall P. Val’s admonishment of Day after the Preakness – “He tried to screw me all the way around the turn,” when P. Val was forced to check when Day squeezed him, then rallied by Easy Goer in a stretch drive for the ages.

  3. That truly was an amazing race by Easy Goer, but I’m sorry…Sunday Silence fan here!Hope you feel better real soon!

  4. Glad you all enjoyed it, folks, and thanks for commenting. It was really fun to go back and read the accounts of the race, and to remember what a superstar Easy Goer was.Elizabeth: I knew that at least a few of you would show up. =)

  5. Thank you soooo much for this post on Easy Goer! He was one of my all time favorites and part of my earliest racing memories. I’ll never forget seeing him in the Travers when I was a young girl, and seeing his grave at Claiborne last year :(. Hope you feel better soon!

  6. That race was one of the reasons I was so high on him for the Derby; I’ll never forget being so disappointed by his loss (although of course in retrospect I feel privileged to have been present for the Sunday Silence/Easy Goer rivalry).Maybe it bodes well that I’m planning to go back to the Derby this year, a mere 20 years after my first visit…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s