“Tanya has proved herself worthy of her ancestry”: The 1904 Spinaway and Hopeful

Once upon a time, there was a horse called Spinaway. She was a chestnut, and she was born in 1878.  Pedigree Query says that she raced nine times and won seven races, and that her career ended when she was three, in 1881. That year, someone in Saratoga named after a stakes race for her.

Spinaway had a daughter, also a chestnut, in 1892.  She was called Handspun, and she was owned, in part, by Harry Payne Whitney, son of William Collins Whitney, the man who had rescued Saratoga at the turn of the last century. She won the Kentucky Stakes and Willow Handicap at two, and she was second in the Matron. At three, she won the Tennessee Oaks.

In 1902, she, too, had a chestnut filly, this one with “white feet and a strip.” Her name was Tanya, and in 1904, she won the race named after her grandmother in its 15th renewal.

“Tanya has,” wrote the New York Times in August of 1904, “proved herself worthy of her ancestry.”

And so she did, winning not only the Spinaway that year, but also the Hopeful. In 1905, she became the second filly to win the Belmont Stakes, and the last until 2007, when another chestnut filly, Rags to Riches, won it.

Tanya was bred by Williams Collins Whitney, who died in February of 1904.  His horses were leased to H. B. Duryea, in whose green and white colors she raced and won as a two-year-old.

Dominant by the time she got to Saratoga, Tanya was a popular filly at the Spa, for both her speed and her pedigree.  The Times said that her “[Spinaway] was so one-sided that there practically was no betting on it,” and went on,

The victory of Tanya appealed strongly to sentiment among the older turfmen, Tanya being the granddaughter of the great race mare for which the stake was named, Spinaway, the best filly of the memorable year in which Hindoo began his turf career.

Ten days after her Spinaway victory, Tanya came back in the Hopeful, carrying 127 pounds, conceding weight to the 10 other horses in the field, and winning by a length and a half. She was of the same foal crop as the remarkable Sysonby, before the Hopeful considered the best two-year-old in training. But…

 The best of the remarkable lot of fillies trained in the stable of H.B. Duryea…has caused horsemen to revise opinions formed when Sysonby of the James R. Keene stable was fresh from his triumph in the Saratoga Special. Even the enthusiasts among Sysonby’s admirers now are willing to admit that Tanya is the Keene colt’s most formidable rival.

 Her race to-day was the most remarkable run by a filly in the memory of turfmen, and her success left not the least room for question that Tanya ranks with the best of her age and sex that the American turf has ever produced. (New York Times)

In October, Duryea dispersed the stock he’d gotten from Whitney at an auction held at Madison Square Garden, an auction that reportedly drew 10,000 people (a New York Rangers sell-out is 18,200).  Whitney’s son, Harry Payne Whitney, bought many of the horses, including Tanya for $7,000 and her dam Handspun for $22,000.  The never-hyperbolic Times called the auction “the most remarkable horse sale ever held in America or probably in the world…”

Tanya ran in the Belmont for Harry Payne Whitney, winning the first Belmont Stakes held at Belmont Park; she finished second the next month in the Lawrence Realization to Sysonby.

Her Pedigree Query page says that Tanya made 12 starts, with a record of 6-2-1, and that she was sent to France in 1912, returning to the United States in 1918. She died in 1929.

She’s not in the Hall of Fame, and she’s not a champion. But she was the first to win both the Spinaway and the Hopeful, something only one other horse, Bee Mac in 1943, has done, and in winning the Hopeful and the Belmont, she joins just 12 other horses in the 120-year history of the two races. The most recent horse to win the Hopeful-Belmont double was Afleet Alex in 2005; before that, it was Affirmed in 1978.  Other notable winners of the two races: Man o’War, Whirlaway, Native Dancer, and Secretariat.

Heady company, that. But in a summer in which we saw Winter Memories win for the second year in a row a race at Saratoga that her mother had won, we might appreciate “most strongly,” like those 1904 older turfmen, Tanya’s victory in the Spinaway, the race named for her mother.



Quoted and consulted

Hotaling, Edward. They’re Off! Horse Racing at Saratoga. Syracuse: Syracuse University        Press, 1995.

Tanya’s Pedigree Query page

Spinaway’s Pedigree Query page

Tanya’s Spinaway Stake,” New York Times, August 4, 1904.

Tanya Won Big Stakes,” New York Times, August 14, 1904. (Hopeful win)

Whitney Horse Sale Draws Crowd of 10,000,” New York Times, October 11, 1904.

Tanya Won Belmont By A Neck From Blandy,” New York Times, May 25, 1905.

The First Belmont at Belmont Park,” Belmont Stakes blog, June 8, 2012.


5 thoughts on ““Tanya has proved herself worthy of her ancestry”: The 1904 Spinaway and Hopeful

  1. Wonderful story, Teresa, thank you. Also, the articles you wrote for the Saratogian on the Adelphi and Three Chimneys were real treats!
    I learn so much from reading your stories – you’re a first-rate teacher!

  2. Teresa,
    The fact that Tanya was related to Spinaway had eluded me. One slight error, however. In 1943, when the Saratoga races were moved to Belmont Park, Bee Mac also accomplished the rare Spinaway/Hopeful exacta.

    • Andrea, thanks so much for that. Happy to know you liked them.

      Allan: Thanks for the correction; I updated the post to reflect it. I knew I was going to miss something…

  3. Teresa,
    Thanks for this cool story. I recently purchased a book from Eclipse Press on Tanya and other great race mares and fillies. Rags to Riches, simply one of the best performances in sports history in the Belmont.
    My first horse and first runner were mares, so I’m kinda sentimental when it comes to the female athletes. A cowboy once told me, you can tell a gelding, you can ask a stallion, but with a mare, you’re gonna have to have a conversation. So to true, but I love my mares and love being around them.

  4. Spinaway in 1880 earned $16,225 toting the colors of George L. Lorillard. Winner of her first five races, she ran second to Pierre Lorillard’s Barrett at Monmouth Park in her next two, and ended the campaign with a pair of victories at Sheepshead Bay.

    She was fast; she carried weight; she delighted the fans; she was game and determined; she overtook front-running competition with a sudden burst of speed; she was backed strongly in the betting ring.

    Among the ten who followed her home in her June 3 debut win in the Juvenile Stakes at Jerome Park were Thora, her stablemate Sir Hugh, and Barrett. She and Thora were co-favorites.

    On June 19 — the first day of racing at the new Sheepshead Bay home of the Coney Island Jockey Club — she defeated four with a sudden rush to win the 5-furlong Foam Stakes. She was even-money favorite.

    Three days later, under 114 pounds, including a 7-pound penalty, she outfinished her co-favorite, Brambaletta and 6 others to win the 5-furlong Surf Stakes.

    July 3 was opening day of Monmouth’s Park first summer meeting, and the second race was the 4-furlong Hopeful Stakes. Spinaway was burdened with 119 pounds (12-pound penalty), but it did not keep her from an easy, 3-length win over four rivals as even-money favorite.

    The fifth success came five days later at the expense of 6 dust eaters in the 5-furlong July Stakes. The easy winner by four lengths was the 1-to-4 favorite despite giving 12 to 15 pounds to the opposition.

    Barrett became the first to beat Spinaway when he led her a length and a half in a new American 6-furlong record of 1:14 flat to take the Autumn Stakes, held August 14th. He carried 110 and was 2-1 second choice. She carried 119 as 3-to-10 favorite in the field of five.

    Despite a furious late charge, Spinaway fell again to Barrett three days later in the Criterion Stakes. In a race that the Brooklyn Daily Eagle correspondent regarded as the best of her career, Spinaway gave Barrett 7 pounds of actual weight, running second as 3-to-5 favorite in the short field of four.

    On opening day at the Sheepshead Bay autumn meeting on September 4, she flashed to a four-length score in the 6-furlong Bouquet Stakes. Here the field of six carried even weights and her dominance was vivid. Barrett ran second as the 9-to-10 favorite; she was even-money second choice.

    The year concluded twelve days later with a race that was little more than a walkover with company. As 1-to-12 favorite in the one-mile Chestnut Hill, her jockey kept her under restraint to finish a half-length clear of her solitary rival, Governeur, who drew a 10-pound advantage.

    Just as Tanya and Handspun were victorious at the Spa, others among Spinaway’s remarkable female kin tasted Saratoga success. Spinaway’s maternal granddam, Ulrica, won the Saratoga Stakes in 1865. Ulrica’s daughter Memento was the 1881 winner of both the Flash Stakes and, keeping it in the family, the first Spinaway Stakes.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s